Stop me if you’ve heard this one before—job growth is slowing, but the economy isn’t in a downturn. Businesses are hesitant to hire, but layoffs remain steady. Workers are staying put, but they aren’t necessarily engaged.

At first glance, the latest January 2025 Jobs Report and December JOLTS data paint a picture of a cooling labour market. The U.S. added 143,000 jobs in January, falling short of expectations, while job openings saw their sharpest decline in 14 months. But dig a little deeper, and it’s clear: this isn’t just about economic uncertainty.

Instead, we’re seeing something bigger at play—AI is reshaping hiring strategies in ways that aren’t fully understood yet. Companies aren’t just pulling back due to financial caution; they’re reassessing which roles will remain essential in an AI-powered future. Meanwhile, employees are feeling stuck—unsure whether to change jobs or stay put as AI-driven transformations unfold.

In this article, we’ll break down what the latest jobs data really means, why AI is playing a bigger role in hiring slowdowns than most realise, and what businesses and HR leaders should do next to navigate this uncertain landscape.

Breaking Down the January 2025 Jobs Report & December 2024 JOLTS Data

The latest jobs data tells a mixed story: while job growth slowed, the labour market remains resilient. Here’s what business leaders and HR professionals need to know.

1. Job Growth Missed Expectations

In January 2025, the U.S. economy added 143,000 jobs, falling short of the 169,000 forecasted. This marks a clear cooling trend compared to 2024’s monthly average of 166,000 jobs (which itself was revised down from 186,000).

Why does this matter? Businesses are hiring at a slower pace, which suggests that demand for workers is easing. However, this isn’t a sign of a crisis—just a shift in hiring strategies.

2. Unemployment Fell to 4.0%

Despite slower job growth, the unemployment rate dropped to 4.0%, lower than the expected 4.1%. This marks the lowest rate since May 2024. It is a great time to hold a job, but a bad time to be looking for a job.  

For business leaders, this means that while hiring may be slowing,  skilled talent will move for the right opportunity and company. This means keeping your most skilled workers engaged is important.

3. Job Openings Saw the Sharpest Decline in Over a Year

According to the December 2024 JOLTS report, job openings dropped by 556,000 to 7.6 million, marking the steepest decline in 14 months.

Fewer job postings indicate that businesses are taking a cautious approach to hiring, possibly due to AI-driven workforce shifts. Instead of aggressively expanding their workforce, many firms are reassessing which roles will be needed in an AI-powered future.

4. Quits Remain Low—A Sign of Workforce Hesitation

The number of people voluntarily quitting their jobs ticked up slightly to 3.2 million, but it remains below pre-pandemic levels.

This signals that employees aren’t quitting out of confidence in finding better jobs—instead, they’re staying put due to uncertainty. Given the rise of AI in the workplace, many workers are questioning their long-term career stability, leading to hesitation in making career moves.

5. Wage Growth Exceeded Expectations

Despite the cooling job market, average hourly earnings rose 0.5% month-over-month and 4.1% year-over-year. This suggests that while job openings are declining, workers who remain employed are still seeing wage gains—at least for now.

What This Means for Businesses

📌 Hiring is slowing, but layoffs remain steady—a sign that businesses are rethinking workforce needs rather than reacting to a downturn.
📌 AI and automation are likely driving hiring hesitation, as companies assess which roles will remain relevant.
📌 Employees are hesitant to switch jobs, due to employers’ pause, leading to a more static workforce, which could impact engagement and productivity.

AI’s Growing Influence on Workforce Strategies

The hiring slowdown isn’t just about economic caution—it’s about AI reshaping workforce strategies. Businesses aren’t just hiring less, they’re redefining which roles will be needed in the future.

1. The ‘Wait-and-See’ Approach to Hiring

Many companies are pausing hiring decisions as they evaluate how AI will impact their workforce needs. Rather than making immediate job cuts, businesses are holding back on hiring to determine which positions will still be relevant in an AI-powered workplace.

As an Economic Advisor to Hatchproof, I suggest that while economic uncertainty has subsided, businesses are now more focused on AI’s long-term impact on workforce dynamics.

📌 Translation for business leaders: If your company isn’t actively hiring, ask yourself—is it due to economic caution, or are you reassessing workforce needs in light of AI?

2. AI-Driven Restructuring Has Already Begun

We’re already seeing AI-related workforce shifts play out in real time:

• Klarna, Workday, and Salesforce have cited AI as a reason for cutting jobs.
• Google employees recently petitioned against job cuts, citing concerns over AI-driven restructuring.
• Administrative and support services have seen a 2% year-over-year decline, suggesting that AI and automation are replacing certain back-office roles.

This isn’t a mass layoff event—but it does signal that businesses are reallocating resources toward automation rather than immediately hiring new talent.

📌 Key takeaway for HR leaders: The focus isn’t just on layoffs—it’s about how AI is shifting the nature of work itself.

3. The Disconnect Between Employees and Employers

AI uncertainty isn’t just affecting hiring—it’s also affecting employee engagement.

• Low quit rates don’t mean workers are happy—they’re staying put because they’re unsure how AI will impact their careers.
• Even highly skilled professionals are facing longer job searches, raising questions about whether AI is changing demand for certain expertise.
• The rise in side hustles and second jobs suggests that many workers are hedging their bets against job instability.

📌 For business leaders: If your employees seem disengaged, it may not be burnout—it may be AI uncertainty.

What This Means for Businesses

📌 Hiring slowdowns aren’t just about the economy—they’re about AI-driven workforce transformation.
📌 Companies must proactively assess which roles will be essential in an AI-powered future.
📌 Employees are hesitant to make career moves, but they’re also uncertain about their long-term future.

Why Employees Feel Stuck: AI Uncertainty & Career Hesitation

If the job market is stable, why do workers seem hesitant to make career moves? The data suggests that employees aren’t quitting because they’re satisfied—they’re staying put because they’re uncertain about AI’s impact on their future.

1. The ‘Great Hesitation’—Workers Aren’t Engaged, They’re Unsure

Historically, a strong job market encourages employees to switch jobs for better pay and opportunities. But the December 2024 JOLTS report tells a different story:

• Quits edged up slightly to 3.2 million, but remained below pre-pandemic levels.
• Layoffs stayed flat at 1.8 million, meaning businesses aren’t aggressively cutting jobs.
• Job openings dropped sharply, signaling that fewer opportunities are available.

Instead of job-hopping for career growth, workers are in a holding pattern, unsure whether their roles will remain relevant in an AI-driven workplace.

📌 For business leaders: Employee hesitation isn’t a sign of satisfaction—it’s a warning sign of disengagement.

2. AI Uncertainty is Reshaping Career Choices

Workers across industries—especially in finance, tech, and administrative roles—are facing AI-driven career uncertainty.

• Some employees fear AI will replace their jobs entirely.
• Others worry that their skills will become obsolete as AI takes over tasks.
• Even highly skilled professionals are experiencing longer periods of unemployment because companies are reassessing talent needs.

Rather than risk a move, many workers are choosing job security over career advancement—at least for now.

📌 For HR leaders: Employees need clarity on AI’s role in the workplace. Without it, they’ll remain disengaged and hesitant to take on new challenges.

3. The Rise of Side Hustles & Underemployment

While traditional job-hopping has slowed, many workers are turning to second jobs and side hustles as a hedge against job instability.

• Some professionals are taking on gig work or freelance roles to diversify their income.
• Others are underemployed, stringing together multiple part-time jobs instead of securing full-time employment.
• A few are experimenting with entrepreneurship, seeing it as a way to future-proof their careers.

📌 What this means: On paper, the labour market looks stable—but in reality, many workers are adapting in unconventional ways to the uncertainty AI brings.

What This Means for Businesses

📌 Employees aren’t quitting—but that doesn’t mean they’re engaged.
📌 AI uncertainty is making workers more risk-averse, which could impact innovation and productivity.
📌 Side hustles and second jobs signal that workers are preparing for AI-driven job disruptions.

What Businesses & Workers Should Do Next

AI isn’t eliminating jobs overnight—but it is changing the way businesses hire, structure their teams, and plan for the future. Business leaders and HR professionals need to take proactive steps to navigate this shift, while employees must adapt to stay competitive in an AI-driven workforce.

1. Employers: Proactively Communicate AI Workforce Strategies

One of the biggest challenges in today’s labour market isn’t just hiring slowdowns—it’s the uncertainty surrounding AI’s role in the workforce. Employees are stuck in limbo because they don’t know what AI means for their jobs.

What business leaders should do:
✅ Be transparent about how AI will impact roles and hiring. If AI will automate certain tasks, help employees understand where their skills still add value.
✅ Invest in reskilling initiatives—instead of waiting for AI disruptions, upskill your workforce to work alongside AI.
✅ Redefine job roles proactively—rather than delaying hiring, clarify which positions will be critical in an AI-powered future.

📌 Bottom line: The longer businesses stay silent on AI’s impact, the more disengaged employees will become.

2. Workers: Adapt & Invest in AI-Proof Skills

The workforce is changing—so employees must stay ahead of automation trends. Even if AI doesn’t replace jobs entirely, it will reshape which skills are most valuable.

What workers should do:
✅ Stay informed—understand how AI is transforming your industry.
✅ Upskill & reskill—focus on developing skills that complement AI, such as problem-solving, creativity, and strategic thinking.
✅ Diversify career opportunities—side hustles and gig work may provide added security in an uncertain job market.

📌 Key takeaway: Workers who actively adapt to AI shifts will have a significant edge over those who wait for change to happen.

3. Keep an Eye on Federal Reserve Policy & Economic Signals

Beyond AI, monetary policy will also impact hiring decisions.

• If wage growth continues rising, the Federal Reserve may keep interest rates elevated in order to curb persistent inflation, keeping borrowing costs high for businesses.
• If job growth slows further, the Fed may intervene, which could boost hiring in certain industries.

📌 For business leaders: Hiring slowdowns may be temporary—stay agile and be prepared to adapt as the economic landscape shifts.

What This Means for Businesses & HR Professionals

📌 AI uncertainty is holding back hiring—but clear workforce strategies can fix that.
📌 Workers need reskilling to stay competitive, and businesses must lead the charge.
📌 The job market isn’t collapsing, but companies must proactively navigate AI-driven change.

Conclusion: The Future of Work is Uncertain, But Not in Crisis

The latest jobs data tells a nuanced story—yes, hiring is slowing, but AI is the real disruptor, not economic weakness. Businesses aren’t just exercising caution; they’re reassessing which roles will remain essential in an AI-driven future. Meanwhile, workers are staying put—not out of confidence, but because they’re unsure what AI means for their careers.

But here’s the bottom line: uncertainty doesn’t have to lead to disengagement. The companies that will thrive in this transition are the ones that proactively communicate their AI strategy, invest in workforce development, and keep employees engaged amid change.

The Future of Work Needs a Smarter Companion.

AI is reshaping work—but companies are still flying blind when it comes to their people.

🔹 Hatchproof is your Behavioral AI Companion for Work, aligning talent, teams, and managers in real time.
🔹 We don’t just track engagement—we predict alignment gaps before they turn into churn.
🔹 From hiring to onboarding to growth, our AI acts, adapts, and guides—so you’re always ahead, never reactive.

The future of work isn’t just AI-powered—it’s AI-aligned. Let’s build smarter teams that stay, scale, and succeed.